![]() ![]() |
"DERRY se meurt ! DADA est mort!" |
![]() (1er Oct. 2004) |
|
Cette course au maillot à pois
rouges entre "chefs coutumiers" peut
s'expliquer en la rapprochant des interventions pour chaman
bousculé, vieilles pierres ripolinées, gamine se peignant
le bide avec
une gammée. Pour meilleure explication, se rappeler
les efforts pour
construire une base aristotologique au ratafia de Yabnev, (sur
Heid'Higler par Lavinas, sur
Freud par Drouillyman...) Les ENÂnes de Service ont perdu l'occase d'une note de synthèse très utile. Qu'ils commencent par enquête à la Faisanderie, modèle de harcèlement socio-religieux... |
2/
John
Searle, the Mills Professor of
Philosophy at the University of California, Berkeley, and one of
Derrida's most eloquent critics, once said that what he found most
deplorable about Derrida and deconstruction
was "the low level of
philosophical argumentation, the deliberate obscurantism of the prose,
the wildly exaggerated claims, and the constant striving to give the
appearance of profundity by making claims that seem paradoxical, but
under analysis often turn out to be silly or trivial."
4/ J'aime le
Foucault, épinglé "histoirien" !
"Like
the historian Michel
Foucault,
he was highly revered — and
reviled. To those of an empirical,
commonsensical mindset, Derrida was remarkable principally for his
verbose and ambiguous prose, and his willingness to ask questions while
appearing reluctant to answer them. Like Foucault, Giles Deleuze and
Jean Baudrillard, Derrida was often derided as a poseur, a "celebrity
philosopher" who lacked the systematic rigour of
the true philosopher,
and who wrote in a deliberately
obscure manner to conceal the emptiness
of its content.
Originally named Jackie by his
mother, Georgette Derrida (née Safar), Jacques Derrida was, like
Albert
Camus, born and raised in Algeria. Being Jewish, however, rendered him
an outsider on two counts. In 1940 Derrida experienced antiSemitic
discrimination at
primary school as a result of the regulations of the
Pétain regime: because of his religion, he was not permitted to
raise
the French flag, the honour usually given to the top pupil in the class.
In fact, in Argelia, the
"anti-this mythe laws" were applied in october 1942, while the USBoats
were loading in Boston for the November North African Conquest.
5/ "Derrida was influenced in his writing by the French-Jewish author Jacob Jabs and the French-Jewish philosopher Emanuel Levinas. Drawing on psychoanalysis, Marxist theory, and Heidegger's philosophy, Derrida's work contributed to a comprehensive rethinking of the basic concepts and categories of Western philosophy. His focus was on the value of written signs, which he claimed traditional western philosophy undervalued in favor of oral ones."
6/ "The problem lies insidiously deeper, in that words like 'culpability', 'corruption', 'crime' and 'punishment', all the terms that constitute the lexicon of malfeasance, have been perverted so as to render debate or an inquiry into their genealogy totally meaningless."
7/ "...by the 1980s, the use
of the term
deconstructionism - like existentialism before it -
was as popular
among newspaper critics and dinner party guests as it was among radical
undergraduates....
|
He
even inspired a rock song by the pop group Scritti
Politti. ("I'm in love with Jacques
Derrida/ Read a page and know what
I needta/ Take apart/ My baby's heart . . ."). Derrida
subsequently met
the lead singer of the group whom he described as "a very intelligent
young man, really knows his Wittgenstein". But he always remained reluctant to define his own philosophy. "The least bad definition," he once admitted, was that deconstruction was "a certain experience of the impossible". |
8/ "Mr.
Derrida is best known as the
founder of the deconstructionist school of philosophy, which sees the
meaning of a text as not definite and unchanging but dependent on how a
reader interprets it."
| 9/ Roger
Scruton,
philosopher: "He's difficult to summarise because it's nonsense. He argues that the meaning of a sign is never revealed in the sign but deferred indefinitely, and that a sign only means something by virtue of its difference from something else. For Derrida, there is no such thing as meaning - it always eludes us and therefore anything goes." Derrida has been mischaracterised - he's not nihilistic or relativistic. He doesn't say, "Everything is equal and you can do what you want." Because there is no God or higher power, you have to take responsibility yourself. |
![]() ![]() |
10/ Richard
Boston,
writer
"Deconstructionism
is what at school, we called parsing.
At Cambridge 10
years later we
called
it practical criticism. Then,
another 10 years later, I became aware
that this familiar pastime had a new name, deconstructionism. It's just
taking things apart. I do, though, have to confess that I have not made
a close study of Jackie Derrida."
11/ Jacques
Derrida, the father of the
pseudo-philosophy of
"Deconstructionism",
has been deconstructed
into
the next world. He had been conducting a terminal "narrative" with
cancer.
Deconstructionism is the nonsensical
infantile "philosophy" that
argues that words have no meaning,
there
are no facts nor truth, and the only thing we can REALLY be absolutely
certain about are that the US and capitalism and Israel are evil and
must be eliminated. Deconstructionism has become something of a
pseudo-intellectual orthodoxy among certain of our academic
colleagues,
especially those in the academic professions that never quite found out
where's the beef. Here in Israel, the Hebrew University last year
granted Derrida, the godfather of the Deconstructionism, an honorary
PhD for his enormous contributions to, well, saying nothing of value
about nothingness. (While technically born Jewish, Derrida had a
long
record of endorsing the Left's set of liberation solutions to the
"problem" of Israel's existence.)
12/ Deconstructionism
is a shallow
form
of Non-Thinking that
has gained popularity among some of the
more
simpleminded disciplines of the academic world. Essentially the same as
post-modernism (how is that for a true nonsense word, something
no
woodchuck could chuck?), Deconstructionism argues that there do not
exist any such things as facts, truth, logic, rationality, nor science.
Nothing in the world exists beyond subjective narratives, each as
legitimate as the next. Language is the ultimate form of tyranny and
source of control over us oppressed folks by those evil elites. There
are no false narratives, just different subjectivities.
But
not agree voluntarily, for society
has (this is the leftist bit) an oppressive structure, so we are
pressured to agree to that version of reality which pleases the people
in charge."
To Derrida's credit, he never
bought
in to the Stalinism so popular among most other French intellectuals.
And Derrida
is only one of the better-known clowns in the three-ring
Deconstructionist Big Top. Michel Foucault
is perhaps even better known
than Derrida. He was a great celebrator of psychedelic drug use,
sado-masochistic anonymous gay sex, cruelty and violence as expressions
of liberation and deepness. There have been allegations that after
discovering that he had picked up AIDS, he intentionally continued
cruising the San Francisco gay scene to infect as many gay men as
possible with the virus. In the autumn of 1983, after Foucault's health
had collapsed and less than a year before his death, he continued to
frequent gay bathhouses and bars. He is best remembered for his motto:
Sex is worth dying for. According to Mark Lilla (The Reckless Mind:
Intellectuals in Politics), Foucault laughed at the idea of 'safe sex'
and apparently said, 'To die for the love of boys: what could be more
beautiful?"
Derrida was only one of the herd
of
fatuous trendy leftist know-nothing Eurotwit
pseudo-thinkers turned
into cult heroes by campus "thinkers." A few years back another
Israeli
university gave a similar honorary doctorate to German
philosopher
Jurgen Habermas. Habermas theory is a watered down nursery
school
chant, where there are no actual conflicts of interests on earth, where
all conflicts in the world are the result of poor communications, and
where all conflict may be resolved through communicative actions
(psychobabble for talking it out). I would like to see Herr Habermas
get himself out of a mugging situation in gang turf in some of my old
Philadelphian stomping grounds using communicative action. But Habermas
had at least been a vocal critic
of German skinheads and neo-Nazis.
Derrida had no such track record. He never even renounced de Man.
![]() |
G.
Lelarge,
"philoManager", Ingénieur informaticien, (Poly of Enfield, National Computing Center, 1970-1973), inscrit expert au Bureau international du travail, (1971 à retraite) suite à contribution informatique, (1965), jugée exceptionnelle par spécialistes du Management. Intervention comme consultant dans 175 entreprises, (50 à 80.000 employés): Philips, IBM WORLD TRADE, SONATRACH, Ministères Algérie, Venezuela, Mines du Zaïre, etc |